OMG I'm so happy right now! Magman originally told me that my wheels would take 2-4 weeks (because he is so busy leading up to xmas), but he ended up doing them in 4 working days so I picked them up today! They look as good as new, even better than I imagined.
The lips/dishes were already in great condition so he just polished them.
He repainted the inner spoke sections, including on the back face.
He even wrapped the wheels up to protect them:
I highly recommend Magman at Punchbowl. It's just one guy named Greg, he's a top bloke.
Now I just have to wait for my hubcentric rings and centre caps to arrive from the US.