I've no idea why, but if you run your battery
totally flat, (easy to do if you leave your door ajar for a day or two) some chargers just won't charge them up. With them in that situation you might think the battery is kaput.
I have two
fairly new modern chargers in that category. One is a 'battery maintenance' type, and the other is a supposedly good brand general use type.
I do however have an ancient heavy
40 year old one that will easily bring a totally flat battery right back.
I suppose there's probably some simple answer why, because the old charger wouldn't have any fancy electronics.