MIDNIT3, check out this article:
http://www.widman.biz/uploads/Transaxle_oil.pdf GL4 oil may be hard to find but it could could be worth the search.
The Penrite GL4 oil (same as you are using) is pretty cheap but still worked fine in my S54 box with smooth shifting even when pushed hard.
However I have now filled up with Amsoil GL4 75W-90 manual trans oil, (MTG) it's a full synthetic.
I only changed because of the heavier grade and I do a few track days. Although it cost
a lot more I can't really notice much difference shifting at this stage compared to the Penrite.